Sunday, August 25, 2013

Blackfish


What I liked:

  • It's a good example of how the internet can be useful.  Now people can do research and make up their own minds on serious topics like this.
  • The video footage and interviews are powerful and moving.
  • It starts the conversation "what is best for these animals?".
  • It brings up interesting points about orca families and bringing together orcas from different parts of the world.

What I didn't like:
  • This is just the start of the conversation.  There is so much more that needs to be discussed.
    • Is it right that Tilikum is being used to breed with his daughters and granddaughters?  What kind of genetic makeup is being passed down from generation to generation?
    • How much space does an orca need to feel comfortable?
    • How much space does any animal need to feel comfortable in captivity?
    • If the animal is endangered, is it ok to have it in captivity?
    • If that animal is hurt and can't live in it's natural environment, is it ok to keep it in captivity?
    • With the oceans being polluted, many marine animals are having a hard time reproducing.  Is it better to keep them in captivity so that they have a chance to reproduce?
    • Is it possible to have the best of both worlds: happy, thriving animals in captivity for humans to marvel at?


Grade: B+







No comments:

Post a Comment